I would suggest multiple themes for the user's to choose through. It would allow Smokyhosts to keep their default theme and please those who want lighter more "cheerful" themes which just make me sick lol. The optional themes wouldn't need to match the theme of smokyhosts since the people who can choose would already be members and wouldn't mind the non-matchingness of the theme.
But as for this being default I would vote to keep it.
EDIT: On another note obviously most of you who suggest a theme change havn't worked with phpbb or vBulleten mods each theme has to have code entered for each mod being displayed on the theme. If you offered assistance to help code the themes I believe more themes would be implemented but normally once I suggest a theme on any website I have, using Php Nuke and have my mods installed I normally don't change themes or have more themes implemented. I'm pretty sure some of the mods added to the forums have been coded into the theme. So unless you find a "catchy" and loving theme for SHAdmin to like and use... chances of a theme change are very slim.
